Key West Restaurants

As we are back in Key West til the end of the year, one of the many questions we are asked is where do we like to eat? While there are literally hundreds of restaurants here on the island, I will only list the ones we actually have eaten at, and our own rating system. Its in two parts, the first the quality for your dollar 🍽, and the quality of its happy hour 🍷 if they offer it. This is a work in progress, so keep checking back.

McDonalds 🍽 🍽 🍽

The only McD on the island all the way to Marathon. Standard food, with substandard service.

Bagatelle. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

Great happy hour, food is great. A must visit.

Best item, Lobster Mac n Cheeze

Roostica. 🍽 🍽 🍽

Good Pizza, not the best on the island

Mr. Z 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽

Great Pizza and steak subs

Best Item, Steak and Cheese Sub

B.O.’s Fish Wagon 🍽 🍽 🍽. 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

Weekly specials,good local dive.

2 4 1 beers from 4-6

Blue Heaven. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷

Louie’s Backyard 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷. $$$$$

Great food, but definitely on high end of cost.

Pepe’s Cafe. 🍽 🍽 🍽

Great local spot

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

One of our favs. 4-630 happy hour.

Best on menu bucket of clams.

Haft Shell Raw Bar. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽. 🍷 🍷 🍷

Good local spot, close by.

Dante’s 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷

Best part is pool, quality of food varies, service fair to sucks.

Smokin Tuna. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷

Good food, always good seafood, HH mixed.

Cuban Coffee Queen 🍽 🍽 🍽.

Great Cuban bagel and coffee.

Pinchers 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

Outstanding food and a great happy hour.

Best bet Tuna Sliders at HH

Wendy’s. 🍽 🍽

Limited fast food on island, slow service at best

Boathouse Bar n Grill. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽. 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

Place is always packed. Worth the wait during HH

White Tarpon. 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽. 🍷🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷

Another fav, great HH specials

Best bet Rotisserie Chicken $6